Skip to content.
Back to Walnut
The Sales Insider
Brought to you by
Video Series
2 min read

Nuts About Sales - Katie Castillo, Sales Development Manager at Postal

Nuts About Sales, Katie Castillo

In our 38th episode of #NutsAboutSales, we heard some amazing sales wisdom from Katie Castillo, a Sales Development Manager at Postal.

Watch this brilliant episode to learn her genius (and delicious) way to get conversations started, understand why it’s essential to use less formal language, and hear about the time she sent a prospect a video of herself sending a gift.

Watch the video or read the transcripts below:

What’s your name and where do you work?

My name is Katie Castillo, and I’m a Sales Development Manager at Postal.

What’s your most embarrassing sales story?

One of my first months as an SDR, I was trying to get in front of a large e-commerce company. I was on his LinkedIn, and there was this beautiful picture of a lake. And my opener was something like, “Wow, your cover photo is beautiful. Is it the Quetico?” And we started a conversation about it, which is great because he’s very high level at this company.

I pitched to him three times. Then, I sent him a gift through Postal, and after that, I sent him a video of me sending the gift.

My commission breath was in full force with this guy, and he never answered me again. So, very, very embarrassing for me.

What was your most genius move to save a deal?

As kind of a side gig, I decorate sugar cookies.

So, I sent personalized sugar cookies out to prospects in order to start those conversations. It’s highly effective when you send someone a cookie with their name on it that they’re going to accept it and set a meeting.

What’s your best sales tip?

Don’t send them an email with calendar times if they’ve already expressed interest. That’s where meetings go to die.

Just send them a calendar invite and follow up with that email that says, “Hey, I just sent over a time. I’m really excited to start the conversation, you can feel free to adjust it if you need to.”

What’s the worst mistake to avoid?

Over-formalizing your language.

I think people want to speak to people. And if you come at them with buzzwords or really formal emails, it’s honestly just going to be background noise or they’re just not going to read it.

Sell me a walnut

Do you like walnuts?

I don’t like oatmeal on its own. But my husband loves oatmeal.

Oatmeal changed for me when he started adding things to it that elevated it. And walnuts are one of those things that when he added it to oatmeal, it made it one of my favorite dishes.

You may also like...

The Sales MiNUT - James Hornick
Video Series

The Sales MiNUT – James Hornick, Chief Growth Officer at Hirewell

Watch this 1-minute video to hear his sales philosophy, learn how to keep prospects’ attention during a demo, and find…
1 min read
Keep reading
The Sales MiNUT - Vince Panozzo
Video Series

The Sales MiNUT – Vince Panozzo, Senior Vice President, Client Partnerships at Hunt Club

Watch this 1-minute video to hear the top 3 things he loves about working in sales, learn how to handle…
1 min read
Keep reading
The Sales MiNUT- Natalie Grace, Director, SMB Sales at The Mom Project
Video Series

The Sales MiNUT- Natalie Grace, Director, SMB Sales at The Mom Project

Watch this 1-minute video to hear what her sales philosophy is, learn what reps should do to make the buying…
1 min read
Keep reading

You sell the best product.
You deserve the best demos.

Never miss a sales hack
Subscribe to our blog to get notified about our latest sales articles.

Let’s get started

Fill out the short form below so we can tailor our offer to your needs.

Are you nuts?!

Appreciate the intention, friend! We're all good. We make a business out of our tech. We don't do this for the money - only for glory. But if you want to keep in touch, we'll be glad to!

Let's keep in touch, you generous philanthropist!

Sign up here!

Fill out the short form below to join the waiting list.